Jump to content

Dvd Drive Selective Reading


Kira

Recommended Posts

GRRRRR!!!

Having just gotten Company of Heroes and looking forward to multiplay with a fellow DangerDog, I discovered that my DVD-RAM drive won't read this brand new disk. It won't even display that there's a disk in the drive after humming along "attempting" to read it. I did the usual, open/close drive several times trying to get it to auto-read, and manually opening it in My Computer, etc, but no luck. It won't even acknowledge the fact that there's a disk with anything on it in the drive for this disk; it's just blank, yet it asks if I want to write to disk... but doesn't show anything like I've come to expect from blank CDRWs in the imaging. Odder and odder.

Then I had a think. I wondered "Why is it that my original Battlefield disks (5 if not closer to 10 years old) work fine, yet my ArmA 2 disks aren't recognized by this drive?" A quick search revealed that the Battlefield disks are CDs while the ArmA 2 disks are DVDs. It appears that my DVD drive has gotten stubborn, a little long in the tooth (old), or both, and refuses to read DVDs anymore.

But that's not the case, either. IL2, LOMAC, Silent Hunter 4, and ArmA (the first one), all DVD disks, read just fine. So what's going on here? Truly selective reading, so it seems.

Hummmmm....

I've attempted updating firmware, no luck. My next guess due to research is multiple media (movies) reading programs in conflict. This sounds possible, but I'm at a bit of a loss as to how to start looking for these programs, assuming I even have multiples (or any, for that matter) installed, which I doubt, as I don't recall installing any the last time I did a complete OS (Win XP) reinstall.

I also pulled the manual connection to power and SATA data link to CPU, cleaned and replugged them in. No luck.

After a chat with the few (where the heck are all you guys, anyway???) people on Saturday afternoon/evening coops, I narrowed down a far more likely issue, that, come to think of it, makes the most sense. Quite simply, the drive is old and has likely had a partial failure. It'll read some, but not all disks, weather CD or DVD, it's choice. Sounds like the only viable solution is a replacement DVD-CDRW drive.

Thought I'd post here just in case anyone had any more ideas before I went that route.

System Stats:

AMD Athlon 64 X2 Dual

Core Processor 6000+

3.01GHz, 3.0 GB DDR2 RAM

Win XP Home SP2 (ver 2002)

Nvidia GT 240

DVD drive:

Lite-On DVDRW LH-20A1S

The drive is approximately 4 years old, but it gets moderate to heavy use.

Thanks for any thoughts, suggestions, etc.

Kira

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1. DDz Quorum

Maybe try it on a friends computer see if his optical drive gets it to work. I had a hell of a time with CDs and DVDs on two brand new computers but thats another long story.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks, Pooka. I thought I'd had that, apparently just thinking about it, but didn't write it.

I did install the program successfully on another computer, so the DVD is working just fine. Was in the process of moving it piece by piece to this one, and ended up deleting it manually. That computer runs Vista, which I'm not very familiar with. When I tried to reinstall, it told me the game was already installed (typical when you don't run the program's integrated uninstall feature), and setup crashed. There's got to be a bit or piece somewhere other than the folder I installed it to, I'd think, but not being familiar with Vista, I have no idea where to look, nor what such a file might be titled.

Research on Vista tomorrow! :icon_study:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1. DDz Quorum

Check for a firmware upgrade for your DVD drive, most manufacturers have updates and utilities, these often resolve read issues with DVDs.

Re: vista and uninstall/re-install.

Installs are tracked in 2 places, registry and an installation tracking directory under c:\program files\common\

There was a utility that will clear out this stuff but has been discontinued by MS, MSICUU2.exe, and you may be able to get a copy from the web - use at own risk!

A regcleaner will fix the registry aspect, and I would recomend that course..

A search of the hard drive for files containing the product name may reveal the installer DB location, moving any files found to a safe location may re-enable a re-install.

You should NEVER manually remove a program, always use the uninstall utility to prevent these issues!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've done some research, and the results are not promising. I was thinking about going with the same drive, a LiteOn LH-20A1S, since this old one lasted almost four (five, three?) years without fail. First problem was that I couldn't seem to find it at "local(ish)" vendors. Second was that the "replacement", the newer version, with all but identical capabilities (LiteOn iHAP122, and iHAP422), had mixed reviews, but the cons seemed ugly. Basically that they had the same issue I'm having with mine (failure to recognize DVDs, CDs, anything at all), but right out of the box.

Then again, it's a cheap drive, and one gets what one pays for.

What are you all using, as a point of comparison?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1. DDz Quorum

Comparison?

A few years ago, I spent a silly amount of money on a Sony DVD DL drive... it worked. And it broke down.

Nowadays, I just by what the shop has. As cheap as possible. And those work too.

Initially, they all work fine, and yes, depending on how much you use 'm, they all wear out and brake down.

So, I'm going for availability first, then cheapability... :icon_cyclops_ani:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1. DDz Quorum
  • 2. Administrators

I use a pair of LG DVD-RAM drives for a few reasons

1) They're SATA

2) They're reliable

3) They're cheap(ish)

4) They come with a black bezel so match the rest of the case.

5) And two in case one breaks down

I try and alternate between the two drives to even out the wear.

Jabo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And Jabo gets the prize! I happened to be upstate today, in an area that actually has decent stores with decent stuff for sale, and figured I'd pop in to a computer place just to see.

Ended up leaving with an LG GH24 CDRW etc reader/writer multi-drive and ARMA 2 Reinforcements (British Armed Forces and PMC combi-pack). No more than 10 min of setup later, and I'd started ARMA 2 loading up successfully. It now runs without the slightest hiccup, OA currently uploading. Yee-Haw! And the like.

Methinks it's going to be a late night! :laughing7:

Thanks to all who posted advice/support/whathaveyou. Much appreciated! :thumbsu:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 72 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...